The Best Sandwich Shops In South Tampa: Mouth Watering Toasted Subs & Cold Cuts Close to Home

Welcome to the flavorful journey of South Tampa's finest sandwich shops! Nestled amongst the picturesque locales and lively markets of this vibrant area, a tapestry of tantalizing sandwich delicacies awaits your arrival. Whether you're a local food connoisseur or a traveling foodie, the hunt for the ultimate sandwich in these hidden jewels will turn your regular meal into an unforgettable culinary adventure. This guide introduces you to some handpicked sandwich hubs of South Tampa, recognized for their mouthwatering fare, quirky ambiance, and an unwavering passion for sandwich artistry. From traditional treats to creative masterpieces, prepare to bookmark these places on your must-visit checklist.

Buddy Brew Coffee

Address: Buddy Brew Coffee - Hyde Park, 1605 W Snow Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

Lovingly named after a Labrador retriever, Buddy Brew Coffee is the kind of place that corporate food chains can't replicate - although there are seven locations across Tampa. Each one is kept authentic by the owners' unwavering passion for serving great drinks and food. Every cup of Joe served and sandwich made comes from only the best specialty-grade and ethically sourced ingredients. You'll definitely want to try a Buddy Brew breakfast sandwich the next time you're anywhere within the vicinity of Kennedy, Hyde Park, USF, Bay to Bay, Sarasota, Park Tower, or Armature Works. The Kennedy, The Hangover, and The TBR sandwiches are also great all-day staples in Buddy Brew Coffee's popular sandwich catalog.

Wright’s Gourmet House

Address: 1200 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33629

While sandwiches might not be the first food that comes to mind when you hear the word 'gourmet', this place proves they can be so. Wright’s is a well-established bakery and catering establishment that has served the Tampa community since 1963. Locals love their delicious offering of cakes and other sugary sweets, which are all made in-house. The sandwiches are also pretty famous. How could they not be when the beef is roasted fresh and the sauces made using signature recipes? Wright’s Gourmet House's diverse assortment of deli meats can accommodate any taste pallet. Its salads are a perfect substitute for those who would rather not go for a sandwich.

Healthy N’ Fresh Cafe

Address: 3648 Henderson Blvd, Tampa, FL 33609

Healthy N' Fresh is, well, healthy and fresh. This cafe prides itself on using locally-sourced, all-natural ingredients to create delicious and nutritious meals. Their menu includes a variety of options, many of which are vegan and vegetarian-friendly. Aside from staples like turkey, chicken, pork, tuna, and salmon, select sandwich recipes exclusively use plant-based proteins like avocado, chickpeas, and hummus. Gluten-free folks who can't eat sandwiches will appreciate additional gluten-free snacks, soups, and hot bowls.

Barrow’s

Address: 3660 Henderson Blvd, Tampa, FL 33609

Another gourmet deli known for its signature sandwiches is Barrow's. Since opening in 1984, it's been a local favorite for its high-quality, freshly-made sandwiches and soups. They've got more than your basic combination of meat and cheese - the menu lists six different types of roast beef recipes alone. There are also turkey, chicken, egg salad, and vegetarian options. If you're looking to really take your sandwich to the next level, consider a specialty selection like the Chicken Bacon Ranch or the Triple Decker Club. But let's not forget about the bread. Barrow's stocks many different kinds, from classic pumpernickel to ciabatta. Kids get their own choice of sandwiches, too. The 'Premium peanut butter' in PB & Js and American, Cheddar, Swiss, Havarti, or Provolone cheese in grilled cheese sandwiches sure beat whatever you've got lying around in the kitchen.

Goody Goody Burgers

Address: 1601 W Swann Ave, Tampa, FL 33606

Goody Goody Burgers makes good - no, great - burgers. But its sandwiches are also quite spectacular. The limited options make sense when you taste any one of them. It's clear that each of the five recipes was crafted with intention and care. Discover augmented takes on all-time classics with the B.L.T. or Roaster Turkey Club. Sliced Corn Beef sandwiches and Fried Chicken sandwiches may not sound groundbreaking, but Goody Goody Burgers adds their signature twist to elevate these dishes to a whole new level of flavor. If you're having trouble picking, you can't go wrong with the Patty Melt – a mouth-watering combination of juicy beef, sautéed onions, and melted Swiss cheese on marble rye bread. Trust us, it's worth the hype.